How do I order custom cookies?
Simply fill out the order form below with as much detail as possible about the colours, designs, or themes that you would like for your cookies. We'll reply immediately via email to confirm receipt of your order request. You can reply to that email with any reference or inspiration images if applicable. We'll be in touch shortly if we have any questions or ideas to add and provide you with a quote.
Your order will not be confirmed until you have accepted the quote and paid for the order in full.
How much do the cookies cost and how do I pay?
Custom cookies start at $6 each. The price may go up from there depending on the number of colours requested or the level of intricacy in the designs as well as the addition of things like airbrushing, custom fonts or logos, edible gold etc...
Please fill out the order form with as much information as possible so that we can provide you with an accurate quote.
Once you approve the quote, you can pay by debit or credit. We also accept (and prefer) e-transfers sent to
How much notice do I need to give for ordering cookies?
Custom cookies require a minimum of 2 weeks notice. If it is less than 2 weeks, please email Sugar Mama directly (email@example.com) to see if we can squeeze you in. We always try our best to make cookies for whomever wants them! A rush service fee may be applied.
How long do the cookies stay fresh?
Our sugar cookies will stay fresh for 1 week if left in their individually heat-sealed bags.
Our sugars cookies also freeze very well. They can be placed in a freezer bag or airtight container and frozen for up 6 months. Allow for cookies to come to room temperature still in the freezer bag or airtight container before taking them out of their packages to prevent condensation on the icing design.
What flavor are your cookies?
Sugar Mama's signature sugar cookie is unlike any sugar cookie you have ever had before! Unlike most standard vanilla sugar cookies, ours have subtle notes of cinnamon, ginger, allspice, and clove. Our cookies are soft and buttery and not overly sweet.
Do you make nut-free, gluten free, or vegan cookies?
We do offer vegan and gluten-free cookies. These start at $7.50 per cookie. PLEASE NOTE Our gluten-free and vegan cookies are made in the same kitchen as our standard cookies, so they may contain traces of wheat-flour or milk, butter, or eggs. Our gluten-free cookies are intended for those with gluten sensitivities, but are NOT recommended for those with celiac disease.
We are not a nut-free facility and can not offer nut-free at this time.
Can you deliver or ship your cookies?
Currently we only offer delivery for our bakery cookies. All custom orders are for pick up only. We are opening up our storefront cookie shop and cafe this fall. When we do, we will be able to offer delivery.
Standard shipping rates apply. We currently only ship within Canada.
Is there a minimum order amount?
Yes. As it is extremely time consuming to make and mix custom colours for every order as well as design each individual cookie, we require a 1 dozen minimum order.